Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

Judicial shockers ... Latest from the trouble prone Queensland branch of the Federales ... Administrative law upsets ... Sandy Street overturned ... On the level in Canberra ... Missing aged care accountant ... Law shop managing director skewered ... Ginger Snatch reports from courtrooms around the nation ... Read more >> 

Politics Media Law Society


Smoke and mirrors ... Spiritual notes … Bishop fends off claim for damages from victim of priestly abuse … How does this work? … Victoria protects politician with DV offences … An oppressive no-publication regime … Celebrity judge battles antisemitism from the gala dinner circuit ... Read on ... 

This area does not yet contain any content.
Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

It's Hitlerish ... Reelection of a charlatan ... Republicans take popular vote for the first time in 20 years ... Amnesia ... Trashing a democracy ... Trump and his team of troubled men ... Mainstream media wilts in the eye of the storm ... Depravity, greed and revenge are the new normal ... Roger Fitch files from Washington ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


Change of guard at the High Court ... Richard Glenn appointed CEO and Executive Director of the Court ... The same Richard Glenn who as Commonwealth Ombudsman was birched over mishandling a report into the legality of Robodebt ... More >> 

Justinian's Bloggers

Shmagatha Shmistie 2.0 ... Another round with Vardy and Rooney ... Remote evidence from a witness - on the bus ... Brazilian magistrate looses his shirt ... CV qualifications propped up by pork pies ... Fast justice by Scissors & Paste ... Floyd Alexander-Hunt in London with the latest regrettable court-related conduct ... Read more >> 

"Today is about Dad's wishes and confirming all of our support for him and for his wishes. It shouldn't be difficult or controversial. Love you, Lachlan."   

Lachlan Murdoch's text message to his sister Elisabeth on the eve of a special meeting to discuss altering the family trust so that Lachlan would run and control News Corp and Fox News ... Quoted in the opinion of the Nevada Probate Commissioner who ruled against changing the terms of the trust ... The New York Times, December 9, 2024 ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

The great interceptor ... Rugby League ... Dennis Tutty and the try he shouldn't have scored ... Case that changed the face of professional sport ... Growth of the player associations, courtesy of the Barwick High Court ... Free kick ... Restraint of trade ... Braham Dabscheck comments ... Read more ... 


Justinian's archive

Litigation's artful delays ... From Justinian's archive ... April 22, 2014 ... Lawyers and the complexity of litigation ... Delay as a defence tactic ... Access to justice includes preventing access to justice ... Reprising the Flower & Hart saga with starring role by Ian Callinan QC ... Abuse of process ... Queensland CJ declined to intervene ... Tulkinghorn on the case  ... Read more ... 


 

 

« Gideon Haigh | Main | Tokyo Trial »
Thursday
Jul082021

National Treasure

Operation Yewtree comes to iView ... How the criminal law does a job on the survivors ... The family "choose" to believe him, until they don't ... Multiple women and their complaints come forward ... Shades of Bill, Rolf and Craig ... Miss Lumière gives her view

The Finchleys

Robbie Coltrane gives a cracker (pun intended) of a performance in the British TV series National Treasure, now streaming on ABC iView.

But that's only one reason to tune into this darkly scintillating four- part drama from the pen of prolific playwright and screenwriter Jack Thorne.

Produced in 2016 (after the Rolf Harris and Jimmy Savile scandals) National Treasure is based on Operation Yewtree, the British police investigation that uncovered many more instances of sex crimes by powerful men.

Elsewhere, it presages some more recent cases, notably against Bill Cosby in America and in Australia against Craig McLachlan - the former Central Coast tradie, tousle-haired soapie heartthrob, infamous Frank-N-Furter and genial country doctor, Lucien Blake. 

The plot is disturbingly similar, male aesthetics aside.

Coltrane, a gargantuan talent who uses his equally gargantuan girth to dramatic effect, plays Paul Finchley, a beloved if faded funny man and quiz show host, now semi-retired in London suburbia with his wife of 50 years Marie - Julie Walters channelling every tight-faced, long-suffering Catholic woman of indeterminate age since World War 11.

Finchley's comfortable existence starts to unravel when a former babysitter alleges he sexually abused her over three nights when she was 15.

Like the Cosby and McLachlan cases, other women come forward in quick succession, one with a rape allegation dating from the early nineties.

"They think I'm Jimmy fucking Savile," Finchley complains.

Finchley's legal investigator Gerry (a sleazy, compelling Mark Lewis Jones) puts it thus:

"Seven (complainants) is about what you'd expect in cases like these ..."

Finchley is unfazed. He hires the best legal advice (read ruthless, media-savvy and cynical) in solicitor Jerome Sharp (Babou Ceesay) and female silk Zoe Darwin (Kerry Fox).

Underneath however, things are unravelling. His drug-addled daughter Dee, played with brittle brilliance by Andrea Riseborough, has been alienated from both her parents for some time and the reason why forms part of the doubt that propels both the action and the interaction.

Thorne's grasp of dysfunctional family dynamics is so sharp that the exchanges between Finchley, Marie and Dee become more terrifying with each episode.

Thorne's dialogue bites, chews and spits out accusations and recriminations. Are they truths? Who knows? Who decides? 

These questions remain suspended in the increasingly fetid air right up until the final episode, which sees Finchley face two of his accusers in The Old Bailey.

By this time, and after the usual tabloid media hatchet work, Finchley's bonhomie has been reduced to pure arrogance driven by the unvarnished will to survive. 

These scenes, mainly of cross examination, are brutal in their detail, with Finchley and his accusers framed in unflinching close-up. 

Thorne and his director Marc Munden make a devastating meal of the women's evidence. 

As Marie, who is beginning to see the ugliness beneath her marriage, says to her husband, "They were destroyed up there".

So in some part, is Paul Finchley, and everything he holds dear, including his idea of himself.

It's not a pretty picture of how the criminal law works in such cases, but an accurate one. 

Coltrane's performance is so nuanced, it is difficult to pinpoint the exact moment at which his true persona is laid bare, but once illuminated it cannot be unseen. 

Bill Cosby and Craig McLachlan must be hoping they remain safely beyond the footlights (their recent acquittals notwithstanding). 

*National Treasure is streaming now on ABC iView. 

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.