Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

Spotlight on McClintock ... Former defamation silk takes the podium ... Speech and fielding questions in clubland ... Jabs at enemies ... Why fewer punters are suing ... Cross-examining journalists ... Fun cases ... When not to sue ... From Ginger Snatch at lunch ... Read more >> 

Politics Media Law Society


A Christmas card from 500 Words ... It's Christmas – time to consider Trump, Lehrmann, and Dutton's connections to the word "rape" … It's not Christmas without Lady Mary Fairfax … US Ambassador to Australia – looking for someone from the "diplomatic clown car" ... Read on ... 

This area does not yet contain any content.
Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

Bird on the wing ... Child abuse and the Catholic Church ... High Court veers clear of a "skeletal fracture" of the common law ... "Control" and independent contractors ... Vicarious liability ... Ignoring common law developments elsewhere ... Australia's exceptionalism ... Ass and the law ... Procrustes revisits Bishop Bird and DP ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian's Bloggers

Shmagatha Shmistie 2.0 ... Another round with Vardy and Rooney ... Remote evidence from a witness - on the bus ... Brazilian magistrate looses his shirt ... CV qualifications propped up by pork pies ... Fast justice by Scissors & Paste ... Floyd Alexander-Hunt in London with the latest regrettable court-related conduct ... Read more >> 

"Today is about Dad's wishes and confirming all of our support for him and for his wishes. It shouldn't be difficult or controversial. Love you, Lachlan."   

Lachlan Murdoch's text message to his sister Elisabeth on the eve of a special meeting to discuss altering the family trust so that Lachlan would run and control News Corp and Fox News ... Quoted in the opinion of the Nevada Probate Commissioner who ruled against changing the terms of the trust ... The New York Times, December 9, 2024 ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

The great interceptor ... Rugby League ... Dennis Tutty and the try he shouldn't have scored ... Case that changed the face of professional sport ... Growth of the player associations, courtesy of the Barwick High Court ... Free kick ... Restraint of trade ... Braham Dabscheck comments ... Read more ... 


Justinian's archive

Litigation's artful delays ... From Justinian's archive ... April 22, 2014 ... Lawyers and the complexity of litigation ... Delay as a defence tactic ... Access to justice includes preventing access to justice ... Reprising the Flower & Hart saga with starring role by Ian Callinan QC ... Abuse of process ... Queensland CJ declined to intervene ... Tulkinghorn on the case  ... Read more ... 


 

 

« Shmagatha Shmistie 2.0 | Main | Huis clos »
Monday
Nov252024

A trial for France

French teacher beheaded after showing caricatures of Mohammed to the class ... Young student's false claim ends in tragedy ... Misinformation takes off on social media ... Media storm ... Religion infiltrates public life ... Trials unfold ... Hugh Vuillier reports 

Samuel Paty: a test for laïcité

It began with a lie, small but vicious. Two weeks later, Samuel Paty was dead.

Trials began this month for eight accused of aiding and inciting the young terrorist who beheaded Paty, a secondary school teacher, in 2020 after he showed caricatures of Mohammed in a civics class. 

Paty's murder struck at the core of France. For its teachers, it was personal. 

In many ways, they are the face of laïcité - France's controversial way of separating religion from public life. In classrooms, they uphold the republic's values in the face of a militant Islam. 

Paty's lesson was on freedom - freedom of the press, of expression. Without opinion, he laid out the dilemma: publish offensive cartoons or censor? He shows caricatures of Mohamed, but first, he gave the high school students the chance to leave if they wish. 

The same day, a mother in tears called the school. The principal at the time, Audrey F, recalls the conversation on the stand. Her daughter said Paty had asked Muslim students to raise their hands and leave outright.

In the 19th century, French state teachers were in open rivalry with priests. They brought free education to small towns, while promoting republican values. In 1882, schools were declared "free, mandatory, and laic". Today, laïcité bans overt symbols of faith, from crosses to burkas, in classrooms. Teachers have become targets in a growing cultural conflict.

The Principal remembers how Paty had denied the girl's story. Regretful, he said he never meant harm. But the story grew, passed from parent to parent.

The girl, just thirteen years old, had been suspended for other reasons: absences and rudeness. Still, she told her father, Brahim Chnina, it was punishment for refusing to leave the class. Outraged, he posted the story online. 

But the girl wasn't in the class that day. She lied. 

October 7, 2020: The father and a militant Islamist, Abdelhakim Sefrioui, came to the school, demanding Paty's dismissal. They promised protests, a media storm.

These two are at the center of the current trial. In detention for now four years, they are accused of spreading the girl's false story over social media with the intention to "pick a target ... incite hate [and] prepare multiple crimes".  

The father denied ever having called for Paty to be killed. In court, he addressed the victim's family, and apologised to "that poor teacher who should never have died in those circumstances".

The damage was done. The social media storm, according to the prosecutor, led to Paty's murder. 

October 12, 2020: Paty's name was everywhere, his school, all over social media. The girl's father and the militant had posted videos naming the teacher and what he had done. Calls poured in, journalists, emails, and threats.

Paty asked to be escorted to his car. "I am threatened by local Islamists," he wrote to his colleagues.

France's teachers are carefully watching this case. Antoine Casubolo Ferro, a lawyer for Paty's colleagues told reporters

"They expect the (French) republic, justice, to say: stop, don't mess with teachers ... don't mess with freedom of expression."

Paty's death came during the Charlie Hebdo trials, dealing with the 2015 attack of a satirical magazine in Paris by Islamic radicals. Paty became a martyr of the Republic. Protests erupted nationwide, demanding justice for teachers and reaffirming laïcité.

October 16, 2020: The last day before holidays. The Principal hears the news: a man had been beheaded near the school.

It was Paty.

A young radical of Chechen origin, Abdoullakh Anzorov, had travelled over 100 kilometres to find him. Yet the eighteen-year-old had no idea what Paty looked like. Shockingly, he successfully bribed students to help him. 

Five teens, aged 14 to 15, were convicted in 2023 for their roles in aiding the killer. One had stayed with Anzorov for several hours, describing Paty's clothing and routine, while helping him hide.

Another teen was also convicted. A girl, thirteen-years-old, who was sentenced to eighteen months in prison for "false accusation". 

As the trial unfolds, questions remain. The killer will never stand trial because police shot him dead shortly after the attack. Is social media alone responsible for perpetuating the lie that led to such violence? 

The prosecution is forced to send a message: the Republic will protect teachers in their duty against any threat. And teachers are watching.

In Paty's backpack from the day of the attack, police found a hammer, his last, hopeless defence.

Hugh Vuillier writes on economics, politics, law and history and is based at the London School of Economics 


Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Member Account Required
You must have a member account on this website in order to post comments. Log in to your account to enable posting.